With the three-match ODI series evenly poised at 1-1, India and New Zealand are set to face off in the decisive third ODI at the Holkar Cricket Stadium, Indore, on January 17. As anticipation builds for the series decider, questions around India’s team combination and player roles have once again taken centre stage.

Former India cricketer Mohammed Kaif has openly criticised the Indian team management’s handling of young all-rounder Nitish Kumar Reddy, questioning both his inclusion and clarity of role in the ODI setup. Speaking on his YouTube channel, Kaif expressed disappointment with India’s reading of conditions, particularly in the second ODI played on a slow pitch where India opted for four pacers while New Zealand relied more effectively on spin.

“I do not understand the squad that has been picked,” Kaif said. “On a slow pitch, you played four pacers, while New Zealand, despite spin not being their strength, read the conditions better. I also do not understand Nitish Reddy’s role. The coach and management should clearly define what his job is in this team.”

Kaif questions Nitish Kumar Reddy’s all-rounder tag

Kaif was particularly critical of Reddy being labelled as an all-rounder, asserting that the youngster is currently more of a specialist batter than a genuine bowling option.

“He is only a batter. He is not an all-rounder,” Kaif stated. “The faster the Indian team understands this, the better it will be for them. He does not bowl enough to be considered a sixth bowling option. At best, he is a part-time bowler.”

Kaif also pointed out that captains appear hesitant to use Reddy as a bowler, which undermines the balance of the playing XI. According to him, this lack of trust creates confusion and puts unnecessary pressure on the rest of the bowling unit.

As India looks to clinch the series in Indore, Kaif’s comments have reignited debate around team selection, player roles, and whether India needs clearer long-term planning for young players like Nitish Kumar Reddy in the ODI format.

Navi Mumbai:
UP Warriorz finally opened their account in the ongoing Women’s Premier League (WPL) 2026 after a challenging start to the season, registering a crucial victory against Mumbai Indians Women at the Dr DY Patil Sports Academy on January 15. While Mumbai posted a competitive total of 161 runs, it was Harleen Deol’s composed and aggressive half-century in the run chase that turned the match in UP Warriorz’ favour.

Harleen’s innings carried added significance, coming just days after she found herself at the centre of debate following her retired out dismissal during UPW’s clash against Delhi Capitals Women. The decision, taken due to concerns over the run rate, sparked widespread discussion among fans and former cricketers alike. However, the 25-year-old responded in the best possible manner — with her bat.

Harleen Deol answers critics with match-winning knock

Chasing a target of 162, Harleen played a mature and confident knock, remaining unbeaten on 64 off 39 deliveries, striking boundaries at key moments and ensuring UP Warriorz crossed the line comfortably. Her innings showcased improved shot selection, calm under pressure, and a clear intent to anchor the chase — qualities that had been questioned after the retired out incident.

Her performance not only helped UPW secure their first win of the season, but also silenced doubts surrounding her mindset and adaptability in high-pressure situations.

Harmanpreet Kaur praises Harleen’s mentality

Following the match, Mumbai Indians skipper Harmanpreet Kaur lauded Harleen Deol’s resilience and mental strength, acknowledging her ability to bounce back from a difficult moment.

“Harleen showed what she can bring to the team. She always wants to do well. I was surprised to see her being retired out, but she came today with a positive mindset. Hopefully, she continues playing like this,” Harmanpreet said during the post-match presentation.

The remarks from one of Indian cricket’s most respected leaders further underlined the significance of Harleen’s comeback performance.

‘No point stressing over the retired out’: Harleen Deol

Awarded the Player of the Match, Harleen addressed the controversy calmly, revealing that she chose not to dwell on the previous game and instead focused on preparation and team goals.

“Feels good and happy for the team to get our first win. Even yesterday, I was batting well. Sometimes, the game situation demands something else — like how Chloe can change the scenario quickly. It didn’t go our way that day, but that’s cricket,” Harleen said.

She added:

“Nothing was different today. I got a few boundary balls, and sometimes it’s just your day. I was batting well yesterday too, so there was no point stressing over being retired out.”

A statement innings in WPL 2026

Harleen Deol’s knock stands out as one of the early defining moments of WPL 2026, highlighting the evolving tactical nature of the league, where bold decisions like retiring a batter out can come under scrutiny. More importantly, her response reinforced the importance of mental resilience in elite sport.

With confidence regained and form back on her side, Harleen will be key to UP Warriorz’ campaign as the tournament progresses.

Cricket West Indies (CWI) recently reached out to former captain Nicholas Pooran to explore the possibility of reversing his international retirement ahead of the ICC T20 World Cup 2026. However, despite the board’s efforts, Pooran has made it clear that he intends to stand by his decision to remain retired from international cricket.

Pooran, 29, announced his retirement in June last year, a move that surprised many given his prime age and strong performances in global T20 leagues. While he has continued to feature in franchise cricket around the world, a return to the West Indies setup now appears unlikely.

CWI confirms talks with Pooran

Director of Cricket Miles Bascombe confirmed that the board had held discussions with Pooran, fully aware that the upcoming World Cup was a major consideration.

“We have made every effort to ensure the best players are available to represent the West Indies,” Bascombe told WESN TV. “Pooran was aware the World Cup was coming, and his decision to retire would have been taken with that knowledge.”

Bascombe added that while conversations were held, Pooran recently reiterated that he is comfortable with his choice to step away from international cricket.

“We probed, and he has mentioned not too long ago that he’s quite happy to stick with his decision,” he said.

Board also explored roles for Bravo, Pollard, Russell

In addition to player availability, CWI also reached out to West Indies stalwarts Dwayne Bravo, Kieron Pollard, and Andre Russell to assess whether they could be involved in the team’s management setup for the World Cup.

However, scheduling challenges proved to be a major obstacle.

“The World Cup flows almost directly into the IPL,” Bascombe explained. “Anyone joining the management group would have to sacrifice a significant amount of personal time, spending weeks away from home.”

The tight international and franchise calendar ultimately made it difficult for the former stars to commit to extended roles.

What lies ahead for West Indies

With Pooran firm on his retirement and senior legends unavailable for management positions, West Indies will head into the T20 World Cup relying on their current squad and coaching staff. The board is expected to announce the final squad after the upcoming three-match T20I series against Afghanistan later this month.

While fans may be disappointed by Pooran’s absence, CWI appears focused on moving forward with long-term planning and stability as they prepare for the global tournament.